REL
343 / RLTS 730L: MODERN JEWISH THOUGHT:
ABRAHAM JOSHUA HESCHEL / MORDECAI M. KAPLAN
Emory University
TTh 1:00 - 2:15 Fall 2000
Callaway, S 102 Wrt. Req.: yes
Instructor:
- Professor David R. Blumenthal (7-7545; 634-3833;
reldrb@emory.edu)
- Joshua Peskin, assistant (404-327-9400;
jpeskin@learnlink.emory.edu)
Content:
Abraham Joshua Heschel and Mordecai Kaplan were, probably, the two
most important Jewish religious thinkers of the twentieth century.
Heschel tried to evolve a religious philosophy rooted in religious
experience while Kaplan tried to evolve one rooted in reason and
community. They, thus, embodied the perennial conflict of reason and
feeling in religion. This course will study carefully the key works
of each of these two thinkers, read critiques of their work, and
consider the implications of each.
Texts:
- Abraham J. Heschel, God in Search of Man
[sic].
- Mordecai M. Kaplan, The Meaning of God in Jewish Religion.
- David R. Blumenthal, Facing the Abusing God: A Theology of
Protest
- Arthur Green, Seek My Face; Speak My Name
Recommended:
- Abraham J. Heschel, Who Is Man? [sic].
- Mordecai M. Kaplan, Judaism as a Civilization.
Reserve:
- Abraham J. Heschel, The Insecurity of Freedom.
- "Reflections on Death."
- "No Religion is an Island."
- "The Moral Outrage of Vietnam"
- S. Heschel, "My Father: Abraham Joshua Heschel"
-
- Heschel critical articles:
- D. Blumenthal, "The Inadequacy of the Ecumenical
Response"
- D. Blumenthal, review of Heschel's Maimonides.
- E. Berkovits, "Dr. A. J. Heschel's Theology of Pathos"
- A. Cohen, "The Rhetoric of Faith"
- W. Kaufman, "Beyond the Meaning of Mystery"
-
- Mordecai M. Kaplan, Judaism as a Civilization.
- Questions Jews Ask.
- The New Haggadah.
- Kol Ha-Neshamah.
- "Introduction to The Sabbath Prayerbook"
- D. Blumenthal, "Mordecai M. Kaplan as a Rationalist
Mystic"
-
- Kaplan critical articles:
- "A Declaration about Dr. Kaplan's Siddur"
- E.Borowitz, "The Limits of Naturalism"
- A. Cohen, "Mordecai M. Kaplan"
- E. Berkovits, "Reconstructionist Theology"
Particulars:
- We will read the assigned texts carefully. For this, we will
use the "study partner" system.
-
- Students will be expected to compile a comprehensive critical
bibliography and to report on additional works by each author or
on critiques thereof.
-
- At the end of each unit, we will summarize in writing and also
respond personally to each of the theologies we have studied.
Guidelines on how to do these will be handed out.
-
- Grading will be based on class participation and a final
paper.
-
- Students will need to create two computer files called Heschel
and Kaplan. We will put in them: your biographical sketches, your
critical bibliographies, your summaries, and your critiques. You
can also include your personal resposes to the authors and even a
file of "quotable quotes." This will give you complete Heschel and
Kaplan files for the future.
-
- SYLLABUS
-
-
- Introduction -- 8/31
-
- Abraham Joshua Heschel
-
- Language and Religious Experience -- 9/5,7
- God in Search of Man, Part One
-
- Texts and Religious Experience --9/12,14
- God in Search of Man, Part Two
-
- Deeds and Religious Experience -- 9/19,21
- God in Search of Man, Part Three
-
- Theology in Real Life -- 9/26,28
- The Insecurity of Freedom
- "Reflections on Death."
- "No Religion is an Island."
- "The Moral Outrage of Vietnam"
-
- student reports on other works by Heschel --
10/3,5
-
- critiques of Heschel's work --10/10,12
- S. Heschel, "My Father: Abraham Joshua Heschel"
- D. Blumenthal, "The Inadequacy of the Ecumenical
Response"
- D. Blumenthal, review of Heschel's Maimonides.
- E. Berkovits, "Dr. A.J. Heschel's Theology of Pathos"
- A. Cohen, "The Rhetoric of Faith"
- W. Kaufman, "Beyond the Meaning of Mystery"
-
- (10/17 -- no class; fall break)
-
- open session -- 10/19
- hand in summary of Heschel as well as personal response
-
- Mordecai M. Kaplan
-
- The Challenges to Judaism from Modernity --
10/24,26
- Judaism as a Civilization, 19-27, 36-46.
- Questions Jews Ask, (as relevant).
- The Meaning of God in Modern Jewish Religion,
17-20.
-
- Judaism is a Civilization -- 10/31; 11/2
- Judaism as a Civilization, 389-91, 186-208
(skim).
- Questions Jews Ask, (as relevant).
-
- Repercussions for Faith and Liturgy -- 11/7,9
- "Introduction to The Sabbath Prayerbook"
- Questions Jews Ask, (as relevant).
- The Meaning of God in Modern Jewish Religion, 25-29,
43-57, 106-19, 134-35, 244-64.
- "Mordecai M. Kaplan as a Rationalist Mystic."
-
- student reports on Kol Ha-Neshamah
--11/14,16
-
- (11/23 -- no class; Thanksgiving Day)
-
- critiques of Kaplan's work -- 11/24,28
- "A Declaration about Dr. Kaplan's Siddur"
- E.Borowitz, "The Limits of Naturalism"
- A. Cohen, "Mordecai M. Kaplan"
- E. Berkovits, "Reconstructionist Theology"
-
- open session -- 11/30
- hand in summary of Kaplan as well as personal response
-
- Disciples
-
- Arthur Green -- 12/5
- Seek My Face; Speak My Name
-
- David R. Blumenthal -- 12/7
- Facing the Abusing God: A Theology of Protest
-
- Conclusion -- 12/12
-
-
- Final paper due -- Friday, Dec. 15, 4:30, Department
of Religion office.
return to head of document
GUIDELINES FOR CRITICAL BIBLIOGRAPHY
- Use the Emory data bases.
-
- Use the Web.
-
- Find and give the call number of the two major indexes of
Jewish materials.
-
-
- Thoroughness counts.
-
-
-
- Divide your bibliography into the following parts:
-
- books by ...
-
- books co-authored by ...
-
- articles by ...
-
- anthologies of the works of ...
-
-
- books about ...
-
- articles about ...
-
-
- books critical of ...
-
- articles critical of ...
-
-
- GUIDELINES
-
- HESCHEL SUMMARY AND PERSONAL RESPONSE
-
-
-
- I. A complete summary of Heschel would include the
following:
-
-
- The ineffable
-
- what it is
- relationship to divine pathos
- definition of faith
- definition of spiritual knowledge
-
- Revelation
-
- what it is for God, what it is for humanity
- relationship of revelation to the text of the Bible
-
- Deeds (using Search and Insecurity)
-
- kavvana -- what it is, relationship to ritual
- social justice
-
-
- A few words of critique of Heschel.
-
-
-
- II. Write three or four paragraphs, using the guidelines for
the short reflection paper.
-
-
-
-
-
- INSTRUCTIONS FOR SHORT REFLECTION PAPER
-
-
-
- The purpose of this paper is to give you time to absorb and
reflect on what you have learned and how you are
learning.
-
- There are two questions; please answer both. It is
possible that a strong poem or other response could answer one or
both of these questions indirectly.
-
- There is no "correct answer" for this reflection paper; only
my sense of how thoughtfully you deal with the issues.
-
-
-
- (1) The material and I:
-
- (a) What was my purpose in taking this course? Am I achieving
that purpose?
-
- (b) How did my past experience, values, and culture shape the
way I perceived this material? How has the material changed my
perception of myself and my culture? Or: How did studying this
material heighten my awareness of my assumptions, perceptions, and
positions? How did it affect them?
-
- (c) What was the most emotionally or spiritually difficult
part of this material? What was the part I was most in sympathy
with?
-
-
- (2) The class and I:
-
- (a) How am I relating to my study partner? Am I contributing
to the study session all I could?
-
- (b) With which of my fellow students do I agree? With whom do
I disagree? Are there any non-intellectual, personal dimensions to
this agreement / disagreement? Have I spoken to them on the
subject?
-
- (c) Have I met with someone outside the class to discuss this
material? How did that discussion go?
-
-
-
- GUIDELINES
-
- KAPLAN SUMMARY AND PERSONAL RESPONSE
-
-
-
- I. A complete summary of Kaplan would include the
following:
-
-
- (1) Kaplan's definition of modernity, including science,
history, democracy, freedom, and humanism.
-
- (2) A discussion of the main effects of the ideas of modernity
on pre-modern, classic Judaism, especially in the areas of
hierarchy and authority, and the traditional doctrines of God,
Torah, chosenness, messiah, and redemption.
-
- (3) Identify the following Kaplanian terms: folkways, sancta,
transnaturalism, supernaturalism, evolving religious civilization,
culture, revaluation, salvation, Power / Spirit that makes for
salvation, biculturalism, and a vote but not a veto.
-
- (4) A word about Kaplan's "philosophic mysticism" / spiritual
experientialism + a word about the Reconstructionist
movement.
-
- (5) A few words of critique of Kaplan.
-
-
-
- II. Write three or four paragraphs, using the guidelines for
the short reflection paper.
return to head of document
return
to index of Selected Syllabi
David
Blumenthal's HomePage